Lawsuit accuses DoJ of failure by design through decades-old system and refusal to use new $425m software on freedom of information requests
A new lawsuit alleges that the US Department of Justice (DoJ) intentionally conducts inadequate searches of its records using a decades-old computer system when queried by citizens looking for records that should be available to the public.
Freedom of Information Act (Foia) researcher Ryan Shapiro alleges failure by design in the DoJs protocols for responding to public requests. The Foia law states that agencies must make reasonable efforts to search for the records in electronic form or format.
In an effort to demonstrate that the DoJ does not comply with this provision, Shapiro requested records of his own requests and ran up against the same roadblocks that stymied his progress in previous inquiries. A judge ruled in January that the FBI had acted in a manner fundamentally at odds with the statute.
Now, armed with that ruling, Shapiro hopes to change policy across the entire department. Shapiro filed his suit on the 50th anniversary of Foias passage this month.
Foia requests to the FBI are processed by searching the Automated Case Support system (ACS), a software program that celebrates its 21st birthday this year.
Not only are the records indexed by ACS allegedly inadequate, Shapiro told the Guardian, but the FBI refuses to search the full text of those records as a matter of policy. When few or no records are returned, Shapiro said, the FBI effectively responds sorry, we tried without making use of the much more sophisticated search tools at the disposal of internal requestors.
The FBIs assertion is akin to suggesting that a search of a limited and arbitrarily produced card catalogue at a vast library is as likely to locate book pages containing a specified search term as a full text search of database containing digitized versions of all the books in that library, Shapiro said.
The DoJ has contended to Shapiro and others that only one of ACSs three search functions, the Universal Name Index (Uni), is necessary to fulfill the law. The Uni search does not include the text of the files in the ACS, merely search terms entered or not by the FBI agent handling the case in question.
Shapiro told the Guardian that the reason the DoJ gave for refusing to use its $425m Sentinel software to process Foia requests after ACS had failed to recover records was that a Sentinel search would be needlessly duplicative of the FBIs default ACS UNI index-based searches and wasteful of Bureau resources.
To Shapiro, this is both disingenuous and evidence of the well-documented resistance to this law at the DoJ. A PhD candidate at MIT, Shapiro is at work on a dissertation dealing with the conflict between perceived national security concerns and animal rights.
The Department of Justice has chafed under Foia requirements for even longer than it has used ACS. In 1981, the then FBI director, William H Webster, told the American Bar Association that the DoJ was working with Congress to determine what corrective measures will be taken regarding what it saw as a danger to the security of its investigations from Foia. The department never got its Foia exemption.
The FBIs chief technology officer during the second George W Bush administration, Jack Israel, said he was unimpressed with the system in a Q&A cited in Shapiros complaint with the now-defunct site FierceGovernmentIT. ACS the Automated Case Support system is based on old technology, Israel said four years ago. Its based on an IBM mainframe with legacy database and programming technology, and I would say one of the main things that strikes you as a user of ACS is that youre dealing with the old IBM green screens. Youre not dealing with a web-based environment, which everyone is used to from the internet.
Not only is the interface archaic, but the way that you search data, the way you input data, all of those are archaic, wrote Shapiro in his complaint. Indeed, in 2012 a DoJ commission headed by Webster himself investigating the 2009 Fort Hood shooting called ACS the FBIs most outdated system, noting that [i]t is being phased out in favor of an impressive Web-based successor, Sentinel.
More recently, the FBIs own investigation into the September 11 attacks found that [o]n September 11, 2001, the Bureaus information technology was inadequate to support its counterterrorism mission, noting further that [t]he FBIs legacy investigative information system, the Automated Case Support (ACS), was not very effective in identifying information or supporting investigations.
A DoJ spokesman declined to comment for this article.